Wednesday, October 28, 2015

JOHN CHUCKMAN COMMENT: THE INDEPENDENT ASKS WHAT ARE CHINA AND THE U.S. FIGHTING ABOUT? - PURPOSE OF CHINESE ARTIFICIAL ISLANDS - AMERICA'S BASES AND NUKES ABROAD


COMMENT POSTED TO A STORY IN THE INDEPENDENT


What are China and the United States fighting about?

Please, first, they are not fighting, but there is an unnecessary and unpleasant quarrel going on.

Just imagine a flotilla of Russian or Chinese or Iranian warships entering the Gulf of Mexico and cruising within shouting distance of an American facility.

Let's say, for example, the stolen part of Cuba called Guantanamo, which the United States maintains as a powerful military and dirty operations base completely against the wishes of Cubans.

All hell would break loose.
________________________________

Many of the comments below show just how effective this propaganda from The Independent can be in stirring up war talk among readers.

But China simply has no such policy as “we’re not afraid of war with America” as suggested here. High officials never talk that way.

Anyone who follows China's affairs knows it does not seek war, and it is extremely unusual for the word to even be used by a Chinese official. China is a careful and cautious state.

Note the contrast with the United States, now fighting and killing in half a dozen lands.

Or America’s unrelenting effort to build new military bases. The United States maintains more than a hundred major military bases scattered around the world.

Please, these events in the South China Sea represent nothing more than the United States steaming half way round the world to strut around and show the flag. It is classic school-yard bully behavior done under the guise of nonsense about protecting shipping lanes, but those shipping lanes are under absolutely no threat of any kind.

China's activity in the South China Sea is about its legitimate interests in the area. Their artificial islands are small non-military bases, intended to support Chinese fishing and mineral activities.

It is the United States which has threatening bases all over the planet. The one in Okinawa, for example, has thermonuclear weapons, something completely against the wishes of Japan’s people. As do the ones in Britain and Germany, this last only recently being slated to receive a dozen replacements by America’s newest type of thermonuclear bomb.
___________________________________

Response to a reader writing that he’s been saying to watch out for China for years:

Then you've been saying nonsense for years.


If you had said, “watch out for Americans,” you could claim some early observational powers.