Saturday, February 10, 2018

JOHN CHUCKMAN COMMENT: A PRETTY UNPLEASANT TOTALLY BLACK BUILDING AT THE KOREAN OLYMPICS - WE SEE THE ARCHITECTURE OF TYRANTS TOO OFTEN AT WORLD FAIRS AND EVENTS



COMMENT POSTED TO A COLUMN BY OLIVER WAINWRIGHT IN THE GUARDIAN


The darkest building on Earth: 'An angular black hole waiting to suck you in'
Sprayed with Vantablack Vbx2, a pavilion at the Winter Olympics in South Korea absorbs 99% of light. We talk to its British architect Asif Khan, who also invented the ‘selfie-building’ 


While the intense darkness of the outside, penetrated by the pinpricks of light, is interesting and certainly attention-grabbing, I think that it sustains interest only briefly. A building like this can only be viewed as a one-off, maybe even temporary, much like a pavilion for a World's Fair.

It makes almost no sense in any other context that I can see, and the truth is that after the initial impression of interest, the building is not inviting. Indeed, it is quite off-putting.

Inside is worse. The one picture that you have is an interior devoid of humanity - white, bleak. I am reminded of a set from Stanley Kubrick's 2001, but then in that film he was trying to create a rather less-than-human atmosphere.

I'm sure others disagree, but I think the building a rather costly failure altogether. This is not a space anyone would want to spend time in or to pass by regularly in a neighborhood going to and from home.

I think it fair to describe it as a bit dehumanizing. The soul of a machine, as it were.

But, sadly, that is often the case now with special-event architecture. Just think of Tony Blair's utterly vacuous Millennium Dome - uninteresting, ugly, and fairly useless from day one. I call it Tony Blair’s because he had a role in promoting the empty nothing rather than encouraging something which would make spirits soar on such an occasion. It suited him perfectly, like an empty bag of gas.

It is in fact too often the architecture of tyrants that we see today at World's Fairs and the like. Not always, but it does seem to occur with increasing frequency.