COMMENT POSTED TO AN ARTICLE BY OWEN JONES IN THE GUARDIAN
"We can no longer
pretend the British press is impartial"
Well, Mr. Owen Jones, I can't imagine who it is that you are
addressing.
No well-read person, at least one with fully-operating
critical faculties, has ever pretended that the press is impartial.
Bias and various kinds of favoritism and propaganda have
been with us for as long as the press has existed.
Indeed, in the 18th century, early political
parties started their own newspapers, or formed alliances with existing ones,
precisely to get across their views of things.
One of the oldest tools of outfits like the old Nazi Party
or the Soviet Communist Party was to create newspapers tailored to their propaganda
needs.
The apparent level of bias or propaganda may heat up or cool
down at various times, as with the Guardian’s on-again, off-again campaign over
nonexistent anti-Semitism in Corbyn’s Labour Party, but it is as much an
enduring reality as the sun's rising.
The record of “distinguished” newspapers like The New York
Times or The Washington Post is literally riddled with advocacy, propaganda,
and even disinformation. Actual CIA people were discovered more than once
working for them.
An old CIA hand in the business of “getting stories out
there” once told of sitting down to his “mighty Wurlitzer organ” and hitting
the keys, by which he was referring to the various publications and columnists
who cooperated.
Just why do you think all the old press Moghuls always
wanted to own press empires?
It is for the power to influence others, to intimidate or
accommodate governments, it is for the entree that influence gives in high
places and the ability to gain treatment favorable to your interests or
desires. The ability to make a politician look good or bad to millions of readers
has proved a very powerful tool in getting what you want.
The press is not, and never has been, about genuine news and
journalism, although of course some happens along the way almost by accident as
it were.
It really is only in the advertising brochures for
journalism schools that we find language which naively speaks of journalistic
principles.