Thursday, March 08, 2018

JOHN CHUCKMAN COMMENT: IN MOST COUNTRIES A MILITARY LEADER WHO GAVE ECONOMIC ADVICE WOULD BE IGNORED OR LAUGHED AT - BUT NOT IN AMERICA




COMMENT POSTED TO AN ARTICLE IN THE HILL


Marine Corps leader warns that China is 'weaponizing capital' 

This just has to be one of the dumbest comments I 've ever read from a high-ranking person.

The Marine simply has no idea what he is talking about.

But then Marines are not noted for their intelligence.

When a country accumulates large reserves of another county's currency through the normal operation of trade, then using some that currency reserve to purchase assets is completely normal and the expected thing to do.

China's reserves of US currency would not build up so heavily if they could buy American products in return for what they send America, but America simply makes too few things, at competitive prices, for that to be possible.

China today is the world's manufacturer. It makes almost anything anyone anywhere wants for a competitive price.

The US enjoyed that position for a while after WW II when all its competitors were flattened, but it can never regain it again, no matter what Trump and the Marines say.

The world today is buzzing with competitors in many, many things, competitors who do things better and cheaper than America does them. And more of them are just going to keep coming. That is just a fact and a fact that is not going away.

It's especially ridiculous to hear any American talking about normal direct investment as though it were an evil, both because the statement is economically obtuse and because this is what America itself has done for so long abroad.

Time to grow up, America, and deal with the realities of the world, not indulge in childish fantasies that it can be 1954 again.

You never solve any problem by pretending it is not there, but so many Americans do this about international trade, not recognizing that America is noncompetitive over a whole range of economic activities and not recognizing what a different world it is, one brimming with competitors, compared to 1954.

A good start for America might actually be to trim itself down, getting rid of the bloated, unproductive ball-and-chain it drags around with its military and security agencies – all of it at outrageously high cost – and stop listening to ignorant economic views from Marines.