Monday, February 05, 2018

JOHN CHUCKMAN COMMENT: PEOPLE TRYING TO CONTROL THE RELIGIOUS DRESS OF OTHERS - A COMPLETELY INAPPROPRIATE THING TO ADVOCATE AIMED REGULARLY ONLY AT MUSLIMS - THE CASE OF THE HIJAB



COMMENT POSTED TO AN ARTICLE BY NEENA LALL IN THE INDEPENDENT


I agree the hijab should be banned for very young girls in primary schools – it's not Islamophobic to say that
Neena Lall, the headteacher of a school in East London, has been overruled after attempting to ban the hijab for under-eights.

Stupid advocacy.

Religious garb of any kind should never be banned, unless it has proved dangerous.

I live in a city with a good number of Muslims.

We see hijab on the street and in shops regularly, worn by women and young girls.

It causes no problem. Indeed, it can be quite charming on some young faces.

If you just think about it, it is not very different to the scarves and babushkas many wore just a couple of generations ago.

Readers may enjoy:

_____________________
Response to a comment stressing that the article was about children, not adults:

And do young ultra-Orthodox have any choice about their much stranger appearance?

What people wear, as long as it is not dangerous, is not the business of the state.

And it is most certainly not the business of people like you.

Get a life.
________________________

Response to a comment saying “There seems to be a misunderstanding here. We are not 'banning' the hijab. We are lifting the ban that has been put on muslim women by male, muslim clerics’:

Oh, please, what a pathetic rationalization.

It almost resembles something you would read on extremist sites or from the old USSR.

People's religious garb is none of your d---d business.

And you only invite hostility and promote prejudice with your smokescreen rationalization for prejudice.

Children are guided by their parents in virtually all habits and customs until they reach an age where they begin to make their own decisions.

It's a perfectly reasonable approach: keep the state out of all such matters as well as "buttinskies" like you.